Wake up politicians: The tide has already turned!



Sarkozy: “A decisive moment for the future of a civilised internet”

France unveils anti-piracy plan

French web users caught pirating movies or music could soon be thrown offline.

Those illegally sharing files will face the loss of their net access thanks to a newly-created anti-piracy body granted the wide-ranging powers.

The anti-piracy body comes out of a deal agreed by France’s music and movie makers and its net firms.

The French government is bend to introduce harsh new regulation to prevent illegal file sharing over the Internet. This wouldn’t have surprised me 5 years ago where the benefits of openness and sharing had not been reckonized as benificial in new business models for digital content. (In fact, it does not surprise me that a French government is introducing such measures today. The French are always ages behind when it comes to legislative reforms) But today, every sane person – that is with the exception of those with vested economic interests in maintaining status such as IFPI representatives and their lackey lawyers) understands that criminalizing a whole generation of young consumers of digital users is definitely not the way forward. New business models is the way forward, and there are plenty of ways to make tons of money in a world where file sharing is not closed to be considered as even more harmful as physically harming other people.

Technorati Tags:
,

  1. Andreas Bach Aaen avatar

    Martin,

    could you comment on how the lawsuit in 2001 where a danish teenager was sentenced to pay 100.000 DKK for linking to mp3 files on his homepage on the internet. Another teenager commited suicide before he was convicted.
    Your lawfirm was representing KODA and NCB that accuced the two teenagers together with among others IFPI.
    So when you write:
    —–
    But today, every sane person – that is with the exception of those with vested economic interests in maintaining status such as IFPI representatives and their lackey lawyers) understands that criminalizing a whole generation of young consumers of digital users is definitely not the way forward.
    —–
    I guess that you have learned a lot during the last 6 years. Do you expect the rest of the world to learn as fast as you – with a firsthand experience?

  2. Martin von Haller Groenbaek avatar

    Hi Rasmus, good point. It was not me personally but one of my colleagues who handled the case back in 2001. However, it was in my name that he did, so it is my “responsibility”. I cannot really defend the case on any moral grounds beside the fact that I as a lawyer is legally and morally obligated to represent all my clients the best way that I can within the limits of the law – regardless of where I share their ideologigies. Today, 6-7 years after the court case I am happy to report that my law firm has handled just as many cases where we represented “the other side” that is the file-sharer or the like. And I like to think that we in this respect are doing a better job for whoever our clients may be because we have the experience of being on “both sides of the fence”. But I am glad that you reminded of this what may seem hypocracy on my side 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *